star_munir wrote:Ya Ali Madad,
KIM and Noorum Mubin and many other books are not easily available but from some JK libraries you can get that. And also there is not any farman not to read or recite the Farmans of KIM so if KIM is not avialable in ITRAB it not means in any way that Farmans in it are invalid now. The Farmans in KIM is till now recited in JK.
I was told by ITRAB-USA & CANADA that both books have been pulled and are being pulled. I almost had the ITRAB-CANADA give me the reason but kept it short to Imam's Wishes. I am guessing they didn't want to draw any greef from anyone since things in past were quoted out of both books in REC or Mission Classes or night Schools or Bait-Ul-Ilm and to the Jamet in General.
star_munir wrote:
As you wrote that did you know that Ginans in JK can only be sung (recited) have to be the pre-approved ones from ITRAB ? I know that but I also know that ITRAB has not sole authority in matter of Religion and is not in any way greater then those who have composed the Holy Ginans.
You may have a point there but as it is now in present time it is ITRAB has the authority in the matter of Religion and the Imam has the sole authority to make changes. This was in the Farman Moscow, Russia 1996.
star_munir wrote:
Thanks for informing. I didn't knew that before. I had never heard about that before. I didn't had any reference to what you posted therefore I posted what I had read. I would like to know more about it if you have time or info on it that in which country/ city these JK are going to be built.
Also I would like to know if someboady has forced you or some one is forcing any one to learn Ginans or attend Ginan classes?
You are most welcome. The only reason I came down so harsh on you is because yours and
kasamali previous posts had the tone of knowing the facts and it starts to mislead other readers.
As you may know of the high profile Jamet Khanas (HP-JK) in Abu-Dubai,
Toronto, Canada and San Francisco, CA. Also, the Permanent Centers in Atlanta, GA and Glenview, IL, Kansans City, KS, Lansing, MI (I think the Lansing one may not be the permanent one). These are the some that I know of. If you are really looking for the Architectural Design and what architects had to do in order to satisfy both the zoning and imara requirements you can contact or post for someone to contact you. I know whenever I have visited the new permanent centers in US and in Canada there are designated tour guides who are knowledgeable about the design and why it was constructed that way.
star_munir wrote:
Also I would like to know if someboady has forced you or some one is forcing any one to learn Ginans or attend Ginan classes?
More than one occasion; it would be more like pressure (in recent days) than force. Force would be if you had asked me 15 years ago.
star_munir wrote:
I know about changings made in Ginan and Farman and I would like you to write in your own words what do you felt wrong in that waez or what were its key points if you have enough time so every one can read and discuss on it.
There is a detail article on Alwaez Abu Ali on ismaili.net under topic of ismaili heros.
I think you are referring to Abu Ali's December 2004 Chicago lecture. I am sorry it would be better if you heard it first rather then my take. This way it is unbiased, I hope.